Tom English was strutting his stuff in the Scotland on Sunday yesterday. Gird your loins fellow bloggers. He had his sights set on us:
"This is the reality of the online blogger. They can spout stuff that turns out to be untrue and, when they get it wrong, it never boomerangs back and hurts them. They carry on untouched by the laws of libel that the mainstream media have to contend with and shielded from the mortification that a newspaper or radio reporter would experience if he, or she, went off half-cocked with such a bombshell.
"You learn to be cynical about the cyber bombasts.
"These supposed exclusives from the blog-o-sphere that we’re expected to chase like a cat would a mouse? Sorry, most of them come and go without a squeak of truth."
Funny. What I've done is selectively quote from his piece.
I've come up with quotes that make him look like a Luddite idiot who suspects blogs, Twitter and the internet are filled entirely by crazies.
Maybe he does think that. Maybe he doesn't.
I don't care. He doesn't care that his attempt to destroy the "blog-o-sphere" is framed selectively within the crazy world of Rangers' financial uncertainty.
I'm cynical of cyber-bombasts as well. But Tom English seems to think we're all tarred. And he's the everyman with the brush in his hand.
Every football journalist working in Scotland today is an idiot. They make up stories about transfers, about want-away players and about managers on the verge of the sack.
And they do that without fear. Because:
"They carry on untouched by the laws of libel that the [non-sports] media have to contend with."
They don't. Only an idiot or an addled conspiracy theorist would argue that they do.
Sometimes journalists get it wrong.
Sometimes they don't mean to. But they do. They're rarely publicly mortified when it happens. They move on to the next story, unabashed. Off to search for the next squeak of truth.
Bloggers get it wrong as well.
Some bloggers get it wrong because they're little more than internet trolls who use the medium to further their own agenda.
Some get it wrong because they're crap, because the internet offers a medium to bad writers, untrained journalists and simply bad people that newspapers often - but not always - manage to weed out.
Those bloggers shouldn't live untouched by the rules of libel. Unleash the lawyers on the idiots. Leave the rest of us to it.
Take a look at the specific subject English writes about. Craig Whyte, Rangers and the threat of a football club meeting its end in Govan. (It probably won't.)
Some of the details about Whyte's ownership of Rangers, details now readily acknowledged by the mainstream media, have been broken online.
Some of the legal intricacies of what might - or might not happen - to Rangers have been explored by "new" media outlets in far more depth, with more attention to detail, than newspapers have managed.
These stories have been explored by people who might well have an agenda but who also lack the access to Mr Whyte that Tom English has recently enjoyed.
They're not all hysterical idiots. Arguing that they are suggests the writer is in the throes of hysterical idiocy.
This blog largely takes cover from such issues. Take a look at the tagline. It's not a news site. I've never pretended it is.
There are other sites out there that can do news better. In the chase for breaking stories it's actually the "old" media outlets that tend to lead the way. I've never hidden from acknowledging that.
But there's a middle ground to occupy here, one that (sensible) bloggers tend to be happier to colonise than (unreconstructed) journalists.
All journalists are cowed yes-men bewitched by the cult of modern football.
Nonsense.
All bloggers, Tweeters and forum posters are idiots, making a mockery of the principles of journalism, pissing all over the testament according to Harold Evans.
Ridiculous.
Is it lost on Tom English that the majority of his readers now reach him online, for free?
Rage against the agenda driven fanatics. Rage against the liars and the fantasists.
But don't rage against us all.
Because we're all quickly learning to be cynical about the raging newspaper-bombasts.
Donate to the Scottish Football Blog Blogathon, 19 November 2011
The but 'n' ben of Scottish football. You'll have had your news.
Showing posts with label football bloggers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label football bloggers. Show all posts
Monday, October 31, 2011
Monday, October 10, 2011
The Blogathon: Calling In A Blogging Favour
Bloggers, the Scottish Football Blog needs you!
On 19-20 November I’m doing a 24 hour blogathon to raise money for the Homeless World Cup and Alzheimer Scotland.
I’ll be writing (and researching) a 500 word (or more) blog post every hour for 24 hours.
And I need your help.
To try and get as many people as involved (and donating) as possible I’m looking to Twitter and fellow bloggers for inspiration.
Some of the subjects I write about will be suggested on Twitter and others will come from fellow members of the football blogging world.
And now I’m hoping to recruit those bloggers.
Here’s how it will work:
You’ll choose a topic. Then you’ll write about it, taking a certain side in the argument. It can be as long or as short as you want and you’ve got between now and the weekend of 19-20 November to write it.
On the day I’ll see your post for the very first time and have an hour to come up with a counter-argument.
If you have argued that Hibs are the best football team in the world, I’ll have one hour to write at least 500 words on why Hibs are the worst football team in the world.
If you have argued that Garry Kenneth is the worst football player in the SPL, I’ll have one hour to write at least 500 words on why Garry Kenneth is the best football player in the SPL.
And it's not restricted to Scottish football. For those with a sadistic streak the further you drag me from the comfort of Scotland, the harder the hour will be. I hear tales of distant lands where more than two teams can win the league but I refuse to believe that can be true.
Obviously your site will get full credit, links, Twitter mentions and all the rest. It’s all for charity. And I’ll owe you a massive favour.
If you think you can help out please get in touch by email (corriganreid(at)hotmail(dot)com), through the contact page, comment below or send a tweet on Twitter.
But please don’t tell me what you’d like to write about – I can’t find that out until the day of the blogathon.
Once I’ve got an idea of names and interest I’ll be passing you over to Scott Johnston of thefootyblog.net who will be organising the blogger side of things on the day. (Or will be when I tell him he is).
“But wait, I don’t have a blog.” No problem, if you’re interested in being involved please still get in touch and we’ll try and work something out.
Thanks in advance and I really do appreciate any help that any of you can offer. (And donations, I will really appreciate donations. A lot.)
I’ll be writing about the blogathon regularly in the build up to the 19th and will also be using #fitbablether as a hashtag on Twitter.
Cheers
Tom
Donate to the Scottish Football Blog Blogathon, 19 November 2011
On 19-20 November I’m doing a 24 hour blogathon to raise money for the Homeless World Cup and Alzheimer Scotland.
I’ll be writing (and researching) a 500 word (or more) blog post every hour for 24 hours.
And I need your help.
To try and get as many people as involved (and donating) as possible I’m looking to Twitter and fellow bloggers for inspiration.
Some of the subjects I write about will be suggested on Twitter and others will come from fellow members of the football blogging world.
And now I’m hoping to recruit those bloggers.
Here’s how it will work:
You’ll choose a topic. Then you’ll write about it, taking a certain side in the argument. It can be as long or as short as you want and you’ve got between now and the weekend of 19-20 November to write it.
On the day I’ll see your post for the very first time and have an hour to come up with a counter-argument.
If you have argued that Hibs are the best football team in the world, I’ll have one hour to write at least 500 words on why Hibs are the worst football team in the world.
If you have argued that Garry Kenneth is the worst football player in the SPL, I’ll have one hour to write at least 500 words on why Garry Kenneth is the best football player in the SPL.
And it's not restricted to Scottish football. For those with a sadistic streak the further you drag me from the comfort of Scotland, the harder the hour will be. I hear tales of distant lands where more than two teams can win the league but I refuse to believe that can be true.
Obviously your site will get full credit, links, Twitter mentions and all the rest. It’s all for charity. And I’ll owe you a massive favour.
If you think you can help out please get in touch by email (corriganreid(at)hotmail(dot)com), through the contact page, comment below or send a tweet on Twitter.
But please don’t tell me what you’d like to write about – I can’t find that out until the day of the blogathon.
Once I’ve got an idea of names and interest I’ll be passing you over to Scott Johnston of thefootyblog.net who will be organising the blogger side of things on the day. (Or will be when I tell him he is).
“But wait, I don’t have a blog.” No problem, if you’re interested in being involved please still get in touch and we’ll try and work something out.
Thanks in advance and I really do appreciate any help that any of you can offer. (And donations, I will really appreciate donations. A lot.)
I’ll be writing about the blogathon regularly in the build up to the 19th and will also be using #fitbablether as a hashtag on Twitter.
Cheers
Tom
Donate to the Scottish Football Blog Blogathon, 19 November 2011
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)